Blog
Building a Clearer Picture of Child and Adolescent Mental Health in Brazil
The Stavros Niarchos Foundation (SNF) Global Center for Child and Adolescent Mental Health at the Child Mind Institute has recently published a nationwide systematic review that’s compiled studies, assessments, and interventions on child and adolescent mental health across Brazil. This study facilitates access to peer reviewed evidence-based resources that should be used when making decisions regarding mental health care for Brazilian youth.
This work reflects a broader principle of the SNF Global Center, which is to improve child and adolescent mental health globally by first understanding the needs, strengths, resources, and realities of young people in their local contexts. Landscape research like this can help researchers, policymakers, practitioners, and communities make more informed decisions about where additional research and investments are needed.
It is important to note that the field of science in Brazil has seen significant progress driven by public funding and technological development. The country is today the 13th largest global scientific producer, with a notable emphasis on the health care field. This positioning also stems from a surge in scientific publications, growing at more than double the international rate.
To truly understand the significance of these developments, we must discuss this nationwide systematic review and why it’s so impactful to youth mental health.
What is a systematic review?
A systematic review is similar to a literature review, which involves analyzing evidence from multiple studies. It is called ‘systematic’ because it uses structured methods with a properly defined, transparent, and reproducible process to identify and synthesize the findings of individual studies based on a specific topic or research question.
Why does this type of work matter?
In countries where nationally representative data on child and adolescent mental health remain limited, systematic reviews can help bring together existing evidence and identify important gaps in research. For Brazil specifically, the most available data compares the frequency of mental health diagnoses to global rates. This is not an accurate representation of the nation as a whole because the majority of the data samples are concentrated in the south and southeast states of Brazil — the regions with the highest income.
By synthesizing and organizing data from hundreds of studies and almost a thousand different types of assessments in one place, this systematic review offers the most complete and accurate picture of the current data on child and adolescent mental health challenges in Brazil. This is necessary for identifying the kinds of interventions, programs, and new policies that should be implemented to best support the mental health of the nation’s youth.
What was the methodology behind this systematic review?
Umbrella Search
An umbrella search was conducted consisting of prevalence estimates, assessment instruments, and interventions. The three-arm systematic review used an approach modeled after a similar country-wide systematic review conducted in Greece. Researchers searched for all relevant studies published up to July 18, 2024 — with no language restrictions — since both English and Portuguese keywords related to mental health, children, and Brazil were used.
Source Locations
The information was collected from international databases (e.g., PubMed, PsycINFO, Web of Science), regionally representative databases (e.g., SciELO and LILACS), and dissertations from the Brazilian Digital Library of Thesis and Dissertations (BDTD).
Professional Involvement and Research Focus
The SNF Global Center at the Child Mind Institute convened a panel of eight experts, who conducted a specific search on literature gaps that were identified during extraction via review articles and snowballing inclusions based on relevant analysis. Studies were focused on children and adolescents up to age 19 in Brazil and were excluded if they did not meet these criteria.
What are the key findings?
Mental health rates
It is estimated that around 11-20 percent of children and adolescents meet the diagnostic criteria for at least one type of mental health disorder in Brazil.
Gun violence
Brazil reportedly has the highest number of adolescent deaths from gun violence in the world (10 killed by gun violence out of every 100,000 adolescents), with the majority being homicides of young Black males. Such findings add crucial evidence to support calls for intervention programs incorporating anti-racism goals and culturally responsive tools that better support the mental health of Black children and adolescents in Brazil.
Suicide rates
Suicide rates for Brazilian children and adolescents are generally consistent with global rates but are found to be significantly higher among Indigenous youth. It is important to note that the research and data on Indigenous youth in Brazil is extremely limited, likely resulting from longtime exclusion of these groups from health data.
Self-Harm
Official reports of self-harm among all Brazilian adolescents have become 28 times higher in the past decade. This extreme rise could be partly due to the 2014 policy making reporting self-harm cases mandatory in the Brazilian health system, though underreporting likely still occurs.
Substance use
Surveys conducted at schools found high alcohol consumption among Brazil adolescents, with other substance use concerns including e-cigarettes and illicit drugs.
These findings and scientific data are critical to understanding public health priorities in Brazil and need to be used to shape how youth and adolescent mental health care is understood and addressed.
This review also highlights examples of school-based prevention programs adapted from European and U.S. models that did not produce the intended outcomes when implemented in Brazil, underscoring the importance of rigorous cultural adaptation and local evaluation.
Why is understanding local and cultural context important?
Mental health programs developed in one cultural, or health-system context may not translate directly to another without thoughtful adaptation and evaluation.
For Brazil specifically, various forms of violence have a significant impact on the mental health of children and adolescents. Systemic racism also has a profound effect, placing Black youth at a higher risk of depression, self-harm, substance use, and exposure to violence. Therefore, it is vital to prioritize implementing intervention programs with anti-racist messaging and objectives.
Understanding the cultural context of a nation’s youth population allows us to provide culturally responsive care, education, and resources. If young people identify with the values and language of the material, it is much more likely to be well received and clinically effective.
It is imperative that public funding for mental health care is set aside for creating assessments and interventions that are adapted to local contexts and addresses key impacts on child and adolescent mental wellness in Brazilian communities. And since Brazil is such an expansive nation containing many different cultures, mental health care and resources need to be adaptable to diverse contexts.